DIP Reviews: Discussion vs. Feedback

Mike Parker aldacron at gmail.com
Sun Jan 26 09:01:03 UTC 2020

I'm making a change to the way we solicit feedback during DIP 
review rounds. The goal is to separate explicit feedback from 
discussion. Discussion is vital to the process, but it also makes 
it difficult to find the actionable feedback buried in the 20+ 
pages that some DIP reviews generate (particularly Walter's). So 
henceforward, we're going with two threads per review round: one 
for discussion and one for feedback (critique).

It's all laid out in this blog post:


Also on reddit:


More information about the Digitalmars-d-announce mailing list