This is not just a question.

[Kagamin]

Yonggang Luo Wrote:

> This is not just a question. 
> I think this must be illegal..
> Why? 
> Because we are "private import baseClass;"

private import affects only import, not imported classes, if you want Base to be private, declare *it* private. You can't affect type declarations just by importing them.

> and Now we create the third file that named thirdClass.d;
> The content is.
> 
> module thirdClass;
> private import subClass;
> 
> so if  class Sub:Base is legal, then we also can access Base.

And we can, in fact.

> But the  fact is "private import Base";
> from this clue , we can't access Base Class.
> So it's confusing.

If you can't access anything through private import, lol, why you would need it?