Restricting ++ and --

[grauzone]

d-noob wrote:
> bearophile Wrote:
> 
>> This post is born from a bug I've just removed.
>> In the past I have read more than one C coding standard (or better, lists of coding tips) that warn against bugs caused by ++ and --. They suggest to not use them compound in expressions. They allow to use them when alone on an instruction.
>>
>> Python designers have totally avoided to put those operators in the language, with the rationale they are bug-prone while saving just a little of typing.
>>
>> Removing those operators from D, as Python, may look excessive. So a possible compromise can be:
>> - Deprecate the pre versions:  --x  and ++x
>> - Make them return void, so they can't be used as expressions like this:
>> y = x++;
>> foo(x--);
>> You have to use them as:
>> x++; y = x;
>> x--; foo(x);
>> (So ++ and -- become similar to the Inc() and Dec() functions of Pascal).
>>
>> What problems such changes may cause?
> 
> Apparently you want to change postInc/Dec to be statements to prevent them from returning values (otherwise the expr semantics would need a special case). That would break C compatibility and sounds ridiculous.

D's purpose is to break C compatibility.