review queue: next?

ilya-stromberg ilya-stromberg-2009 at yandex.ru
Thu Oct 3 07:43:54 PDT 2013


On Thursday, 3 October 2013 at 14:23:42 UTC, Dicebot wrote:
> On Thursday, 3 October 2013 at 14:13:58 UTC, ilya-stromberg 
> wrote:
>> What happens if I vote "Yes with condition", but module 
>> developer will not satisfy the condition? My vote will be 
>> calculated as "No", as "Yes", or will not calculated at all?
>> In which term module developer should satisfy the condition if 
>> he wants to do this? Before merge pull request to the Phobos?
>
> Initially it will be counted as "No" vote. Then, if clear "Yes" 
> vote count is not enough to get the module into Phobos, "Yes, 
> but" votes will be evaluated. If those can make the difference, 
> module author will be given the opportunity to satisfy the 
> condition(s) and turn this vote into clear "Yes" without any 
> additional formal review and/or voting. If those do not make 
> the difference, proposal is simply marked as rejected.

OK, I see.
How many conditions I can add? Only one, a few related (for 
example, documentation issues), or unlimited?


More information about the Digitalmars-d mailing list