Antipattern in core.memory.GC.addRange?

Steven Schveighoffer schveiguy at yahoo.com
Fri Sep 22 21:29:10 UTC 2017


GC.addRange has this signature:

static nothrow @nogc void addRange(in void* p, size_t sz, const TypeInfo 
ti = null);

I see a large problem with this. Let's say you malloc an array of struct 
pointers:

struct Foo { ... }

import core.stdc.stdlib;
auto ptrs = (cast(Foo *)malloc(Foo.sizeof * 10))[0 .. 10];

Now, you want to store GC pointers in that block, you need to add the 
range to the GC:

GC.addRange(ptrs.ptr, ptrs.length);

See the problem? Why would addRange work this way, when D has such a 
better mechanism for this? Can we fix it?

-Steve


More information about the Digitalmars-d mailing list