tuple not part of core language

Nick Treleaven nick at geany.org
Thu Feb 5 20:02:47 UTC 2026


On Tuesday, 20 January 2026 at 19:51:33 UTC, Timon Gehr wrote:
> Whether there is a druntime component is an implementation 
> detail (and a lot of existing features require druntime 
> support). However, semantically, I don't think it makes that 
> much sense to add tuples to D that don't behave like `struct`s 
> (except maybe there can be some magic for things like reverse 
> type deduction through tuple literals).

Yes, and compatibility with `std.typecons.Tuple` would be useful. 
Though it would be nice if slicing produced a tuple rather than a 
sequence.

> Anyway, the unpacking DIP did get accepted recently (and 
> pragmatically, unpacking is really the main thing that is 
> missing in D), so we should try to get the implementation ready 
> to merge. (IIRC there is still a known issue involving an ICE 
> on unpack if a tuple component type has both move and copy 
> constructors.)

I suggest submitting a PR to merge your unpacking branch if you 
have time. It's already behind a preview flag, so it doesn't have 
to be perfect. It's easier to test, file bugs and get people to 
see and fix them when it's in the main repo.




More information about the Digitalmars-d-learn mailing list