What are the worst parts of D?

bearophile via Digitalmars-d digitalmars-d at puremagic.com
Wed Sep 24 10:24:37 PDT 2014


Don:

> I agree completely. I would say that the #1 problem in D is the 
> paranoid fear of breaking backwards compatibility. I said that 
> in my 2013 talk. It is still true today.
>
> Sociomantic says, PLEASE BREAK OUR CODE! Get rid of the old 
> design bugs while we still can.

I keep a large amount of working D2 code, mostly for 
scientific-like usages (plus other code outside work, like almost 
one thousand of Rosettacode programs, a lot of lines of very 
carefully written good code). Most of such code is divided in 
many small programs. I have plenty of unittests and I also use 
contract programming. A planned breaking change, if it gives 
clear and nice error messages, allows me to fix the whole code 
base in a limited amount of time (1 hour, or 2 hours or a little 
more), and often it's an easy work that I can do late in the day 
when I am too tired to do more intelligent work anyway. Compared 
to the work to understand the problems, invent the problems, 
invent the solutions, and write working code, the amount of brain 
time & work to keep code updated is not significant for me.

So I suggest to deprecate the built-in sort, deprecate other 
things that are waiting for it since some time, do the other 
language updates that you think are good.

Bye,
bearophile


More information about the Digitalmars-d mailing list