Import paths do not work

Jesse Phillips via Digitalmars-d-learn digitalmars-d-learn at puremagic.com
Thu Jan 29 11:13:24 PST 2015


Let me try to explain the compilation process which may help you 
to understand where your problem lies.

* Build system
	* Maintain program/library dependencies
	* Execute commands resulting in a usable program/library
* Compiler
	* Lexical Analysis
	* Parsing
	* Language translation
	* Optimizations
* Linker
	* Combine machine code from multiple locations
	* Optimizations

Each stage is feeding into the next and interacting with one may 
not require explicit interaction for the next.

=== Linker
The linker is at the bottom of our list because it will be the 
final step in creating an executable/library. There is not one 
single linker, there are many for different operating systems and 
programming languages. The 'ld' linker is common on Linux, 
Windows has a linker called link, and DMD makes use of optlink 
for its 32-bit build.

At the time the linker is called the source code has already been 
translated into machine code by the compiler. So the linker has a 
simple task of packaging up the machine code which makes up your 
program. This means locating the machine code for libraries being 
used and combining it with the instructions you've specified. One 
of the most common errors you'll receive from a linker is that it 
can't find the corresponding machine code.

Consider yourself the linker and, as the compiler, I will request 
that you do some work for me. The programmer has asked me to 
compile decentApp.d for them and makes a call to spiral(). If I 
give you the machine code for decentApp could you please include 
the machine code for famous.awesome.spiral() too? Are you able to 
locate machine code for famous.awesome.spiral?

The answer is that you can't, not with out being told where to 
look, what to look for, or searching every location for any 
machine code matching that symbol (when you make function calls 
the linker doesn't care it is a function, it considers it a 
symbol or reference for some chunk of machine code).

The solution, tell the linker where it will find the code, it is 
just a polite thing to do.

Once the linker has all the code it can perform optimizations, 
one of the most common is throwing out code which isn't being 
used.

=== Compiler
The compiler is a translation tool, making conversion from one 
language to another.

When it translates a chunk of code, there can be references to 
other chunks some of which may have already been compiled, and 
some that may still need compiled. What is important to the 
compiler is making sure that the call out to that chuck of code 
is formed in the agreed upon structure. It does this by examining 
the function signature, in C/C++ we see this information provided 
through a header file.

Since the compiler doesn't have to build every chunk of code that 
the program is being run, as long as it has the function 
signature it can translate code that call into some unknown 
location. And this is where the -I flag comes in play. When you 
provide the -I with a location, it signals to the compiler that 
it should look for the function signatures of this code chunk in 
the locations specified.

However, the compiler does not build the code that it finds, it 
expects you have already done that because you're not telling it 
to build that code. It will then pass off the translated code to 
the linker and request an executable be built.

The linker however only knows about the code the compiler has 
told it about (and some default search locations). If it can find 
it in the code provided by the compiler, or the places it was 
told to search then it will fail.

This is where the -l linker flag comes in (assuming Linux), when 
passed on the compiler it would be -L-l (pass to the linker the 
flag -l). Using -l specifies what libraries to find reference 
code in, and -L is used to specify what directories to look in 
for the requested library.

----

When you tell the compiler to build your code and it will find 
some of the code over here in -I"foo" it is probably wrong if you 
don't also include a -L-l and possibly -L-L in that same command.

Most likely you want a build system that handles dependencies for 
you, check out DUB.


More information about the Digitalmars-d-learn mailing list